Factory Girl
Bottom Line: More successful as a slice of pop-culture history than as
a biopic, despite two powerful leads.
By Sheri Linden
Dec 29, 2006
Sienna Miller plays the ill-fated Andy Warhol muse Edie Sedgwick.
The story of New York it girl, fashion icon and Andy Warhol muse Edie
Sedgwick (1943-71) has taken on the proportions of a cult myth, as do
most true tales of brief, intense lives. Focusing on the year or so in
the mid-1960s when she burned brightest and crashed most dramatically,
"Factory Girl" boasts its own bright intensity, fueled in large part
by leads Sienna Miller and Guy Pearce. Director George Hickenlooper
captures the energy and ultra-irony of Warhol's scene, but his
attempts to give the film a conventional biopic arc end up wallowing
in dime-store psychology. The central performances will generate
strong word-of-mouth for the picture, which enters limited release
today.
A work-in-progress version that the Weinstein Co. screened only weeks
ago had a rawer, more immediate power than the final cut. In
particular, the addition of a framing interview set in 1970 -- with
Miller's Sedgwick in scrubbed California-girl mode, having abandoned
Manhattan, heavy eyeliner and hard drugs -- has a defusing effect,
explaining what already is evident, especially when it is used in
voice-over. Intercut talking-head comments from the likes of George
Plympton and one of Sedgwick's brothers, which provided far more
interesting context and commentary than the current narration by
Sedgwick, are now relegated to the end-credits sequence.
Some of the changes might have to do with Bob Dylan's objections to
the original script and threatened legal action. He apparently was
concerned that the film would draw a cause-and-effect line between the
end of his relationship with Sedgwick and her suicide. (Sedgwick has
long been viewed as a key inspiration to "Blonde on Blonde"-era Dylan,
but whether they did indeed have a love affair appears less likely.)
Coyly unnamed in the film, the famous, scruffy musician who
temporarily draws Edie out of the Warhol orbit is clearly based on
Dylan. If anything, though, the character, played by a charismatic
Hayden Christensen, comes across as the sole voice of reason in
Sedgwick's increasingly out-of-control life.
"Factory Girl" draws a too-easy opposition between the musician's
authenticity and the artificiality of Warhol's world of surfaces. But
at its strongest, it explores a timeless tension between style and
substance, form and meaning. At the center of this tug of war is the
blueblood gamine Sedgwick, a striking beauty and would-be artist whose
unique glamour snags Warhol's heart, inasmuch as he will admit to
having one.
Perhaps the cruelest irony of Sedgwick's story, as it is presented
here, is that she escapes her troubled family, albeit on trust-fund
purse strings, only to end up in the grip of another ultimately
poisonous clan. If there is a villain here besides Edie's father
(James Naughton), the part goes to Warhol (Pearce). After making Edie
the "superstar" of his controversial movies, he jealously guilt-trips
her over her involvement with the rock star. He is an unlikely Oedipal
figure for Sedgwick, whose suspicions toward happy-family facades are
explained in all-too-familiar melodramatic fashion.
Pearce, one of the most versatile of screen actors, is compelling and
witty as the pallid Svengali, for whom society gossip seeps into even
Catholic confession. His anxious, hungry gaze conveys envy, self-
loathing and a childlike fascination with beauty. As the beauty who
for a while captivated him beyond all others, Miller delivers a
powerful performance, often baring all to give us Edie at her most
candlelit exquisite as well as her most degraded. From the throaty
laugh and old-money inflections to the extreme vulnerability,
neediness and intelligence, she brings to life Sedgwick's legendary
allure.
Supporting performances are a mixed bag, ranging from the awkward (a
decidedly unflamboyant Jimmy Fallon as a "flamboyant socialite," Mena
Suvari as rich girl Richie and Illeana Douglas as Diana Vreeland) to
the convincing (Armin Amiri as fellow Factory girl Ondine, Beth Grant
as Andy's mother and Edward Herrmann as the Sedgwick family attorney).
Screenwriter Captain Mauzner, who co-scripted the John Holmes-centered
"Wonderland," indulges in too much explanatory psychologizing. But
stripped of that overlay, his screenplay often sizzles with the self-
conscious humor of smart nonconformists. DP Michael Grady ably helps
Hickenlooper pay homage to Warhol's inventively bad-is-good filmmaking
and renowned B&W screen tests. Playing '60s New York, Shreveport, La.,
lends a fitting vintage feel, while the production design by Jeremy
Reed and John Dunn's costumes create an exuberant blend of high
society and underground scene.
Factory Girl
Bob Yari Prods.
Credits:
Producer: Holly Wiersma
Producer: Bob Yari
Producer: Richard Golub
Producer: Malcolm Petal
Producer: Kimberly C. Anderson
Producer: Morris Bart
Director: George Hickenlooper
Screen Writer: Captain Mauzner
Cast:
Actor: Sienna Miller
Actor: Guy Pearce
Actor: Hayden Christensen
Actor: Jimmy Fallon
MPAA rating: R
Running time: 87